Integrated IDX Vs. Framed IDX Solutions
A real estate website lacking a property search tool is not only non-competitive, but in this day and age, it can be safely called obsolete. Assuming you are a Realtor who sees the importance of keeping up-to-date technologically, the next question is: where to start?
It can be confusing to choose a search tool. There are many questions to ask. Framed? No frames? What is a framed search tool anyways? Do I have to host it myself? Do I have to take a crash course in programming to get it going and keep it going?
There are three primary options, framed, partially integrated, and fully integrated, with the first and last being the most commonly used. They all have both pros and cons, so it makes sense to do your research and make sure you find the right option for your business.
Let’s start with the framed search tool option. When using a framed data feed, the information is obtained by linking to the MLS’s IDX URL with your active agent ID. This can be done by either the Realtor/broker or more likely, by the website designer as it requires an understanding of the technical aspects of site design. Using the MLS’s URL data, you or your designer will build a frameset and then wait until the MLS verifies your information. After verification, you will be able use the search tools. Sounds easy, doesn’t it? Framed IDX provides a hands-off data presentation, which may be preferred if you don’t mind the downsides that come with not having control over the development or hosting.
With a framed search tool from your MLS, you get a cost effective way to send your visitors to a search page, but the benefits pretty much end there. Note some of the downsides to a framed IDX solution that are out of your control: Design – with a framed solution you cannot determine the design of the data display, and with so many integrated options out there, users will often see the un-unified formatting as unprofessional. Search Engine Optimization (or lack thereof) – by sending users to a framed-in page, you are taking your hard earned traffic and passing it off to a non-branded search page, and if this page gets a better ranking due to your linking to it, you won’t see any of the benefits. Lead generation – by sending your users to a MLS search page, you are giving up any ability to capture leads. If the customer wants more information, they will have to contact the listing agent, instead of going straight to you or asking you to get in touch with them. Extra Features – there are no extra features. No saved searches, no automatically emailed updates, and so forth.
The next possible choice is to download the raw data from the MLS and format it yourself. If you’re a programmer on the side or have one already in your employ, this would be a good way to go. You can choose how the data displays, what criteria the consumer can search by and what bells and whistles are available. The downside? You will need to keep on it. When the MLS information updates, you will need to make sure your site is also updated. There is a fair deal of work that goes into maintaining the MLS data feed, but if you are up to the challenge, this may be the right choice for you.
Last but not least is the integrated IDX solution. This is where you, as the agent or broker, subscribe to a custom-made IDX package that is hosted on the vendor’s server. Usually formatted to match your website, the search tools look like any other part of your webpage. Different vendors offer different options. Some, like IDX Broker, will give you access to the tools so that you can change the format, the style and add or delete additional tools such as traffic reports and mortgage calculators. This option is portable, so that if you change websites, you can move your IDX feed easily and quickly. Also, you won’t have to worry about having to learn programming to make it work. You can usually include handy implements such as search saves and email updates that will add benefit from the customer’s standpoint. In addition to this, you can find packages that include lead generation and branding tools that help with your SEO efforts.
The other side of the integrated IDX option is that there are costs associated with it. There is usually a one-time sign up fee and then a monthly fee which changes according to the vendor. You are also reliant on the vendor, so it becomes important to do your homework to make sure the company you choose is consistent and stable.
Depending on what your preferences are, there are many different choices you can make when you are ready to add the invaluable addition of property search tools to your real estate website. What you choose to go with is dependent on just how much interaction you want and how important the look and feel of the information is. Good luck!
Brad Nix
Posted at 06:49h, 01 FebruaryI hope that the comments on this post highlight some of the better alternatives for integrated IDX solutions. I have been considering the move from framed to integrated, but the REW troubles with Google have scared me.
Any reviews or recommendations out there?
Real Estate Chocolate - Ridgefield, CT Real Estate
Posted at 06:18h, 02 FebruaryThanks Kaya… as an agent it can be so hard to make “the best” decision on this stuff. So many vendors, so many promises.
Where do you see vendors like #1 Expert fitting in to the mix? Not idx but offering local listings nonetheless. Do you know what the benefits are from this approach?
Thanks!
Jamie
Posted at 08:46h, 02 FebruaryKaya,
Great post, you touch on many of the alternatives pros and cons and I think it really matters what the agent / broker really wants their website to do for them. Another option, to the ones you pointed out is to utilize the Trulia Publisher Platform (TPP)http://www.trulia.com/publishers/ that we just launched. TPP is essentially a hosted solution that is customizable to integrate with your site and provides the full Trulia search experience and best of all it’s free of charge.
This provides another alternative that can still promote the agent brand, utilizes Trulia’s advanced technology that we maintain and is affordable.
Ultimately there are many options as you point out, so I think it really depends on what your web strategy is and once you decide want you want you can evaluate all the different options.
Jamie
Kaya Hardin
Posted at 16:00h, 04 FebruaryThe SEO concern is certainly a valid one and in fact this is one of the primary reasons you would want to have a branded IDX search page instead one that is framed. I can’t speak to the recent REW troubles, but it’s my understanding that it may have been related to some paid directory listing issues and not any IDX specific issues. As far as the benefits of using an integrated IDX solution, perhaps an example is best here to explain what I am talking about above.
Try this Google search: http://www.google.com/search?q=Harbour+Bay+Homes&btnG=Search
When I searched for this company, the first two organic results are for the company’s primary website and the 4th organic result was for that company’s integrated IDX search page. If you visit the IDX page, you will notice that the page is a branded website complete with search capabilities. The benefit here being that when these IDX pages get picked up by the search engines, the resulting page includes the primary website’s HTML and complete branding.
Now try this search: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Boca+Raton+MLS+Property+Search&btnG=Search
In this case the company’s primary URL (bocaluxuryhomes.com) is not displaying on the 1st page, but the integrated IDX page is the first organic listing you see for this popular search term. Since this IDX page is integrated with the company’s HTML, that page is directed to a company branded website with all the IDX search tools built in, just like the above example.
If either of the two IDX examples above did not include any integrated branding (AKA: framed in) and those IDX pages were to get indexed by the search engines (this is a good thing!), the user would simply be directed to a blank and unbranded IDX search page. It may look good with an iFrame or regular frame when users view this page through your website, but if they find your search tools through any other method, such as a search engine, it’s a sure way to lose a quality lead!
Hubert Hopkins
Posted at 18:20h, 21 AprilWe have been using a framed IDX from Wolfnet with pretty much the results you describe. On the postive side it’s easy to implement on a new website and make custom searches that are run in an iFrame.
The bad news is that it’s an SEO disaster and tracking using Analytics or PPC Conversion code is not possible. Wolfnet has been very non-responsive in fixing these issues, even though they are pretty simple. They apparently have no clue of the importance of SEO and tracking for our agent and broker clients.
We are looking at other solutions including the one you mentioned IDX Broker. If someone has any comments on it’s performance, we would love to hear about it.
Matt L
Posted at 05:59h, 22 AprilMy question is why anybody hasn’t created one that integrates on the customer’s server via php or asp with an include? If the customer stops paying for the service, then shut off delivery on the server side.
Tyler Hill
Posted at 13:56h, 13 MayI have a new website that I have recently started I am waiting on the programer to complete my integrated IDX Feed. It has a lot of glitches, I did this site on trade so I am hoping that I do not need to search or pay for another. I am wondering where I might turn for a short term fix.
Kaya
Posted at 14:23h, 13 MayHi Tyler –
You may want to consider all of the ongoing costs of developing a custom IDX solution with a programmer who doesn’t focus on just IDX sites for a living.
You might be surprised at what a custom IDX solution like idxbroker could offer in terms of customization, not to mention not having to bear the risk of any future changes to the data feed and the relative costs. I realize a “short term fix” might sound like the better option, but I would definitely suggest looking into a long term solution – there are quite a few out there that are reasonably priced and in the long run, save both money and time!
Brian
Posted at 11:25h, 19 SeptemberThis was a terrific explanation of all the Information Systems that go into the Real Estate industry. Thank you very much for this post!
Financial_Expert
Posted at 16:25h, 29 OctoberInteresting post. I have stumbled and twittered this for my friends. Hope others find it as interesting as I did.
Financial Expert
masawebdevelopment.com
cura slabire
Posted at 04:27h, 02 JanuaryI was been after the Internet for this info and i wanted to say thanks to you for this post. Also, just off topic, how can i find a copy of this theme? – Thanks
dieta anului 2010
Posted at 00:29h, 03 JanuaryI was beeing looking the Web for this information and just wanted to thank you for this post. By the way, just off topic, how can i find a copy of this theme? – 10x
cura slabire
Posted at 00:37h, 04 JanuaryI have beeing after the Web for such information and just wanted to say thanks to u for this post. By the way, just off topic, where can i get a version of this theme? – 10x
dean
Posted at 13:14h, 19 MarchReally, framed IDX is outdated, might have been good in the mid-2000s, but now its integrated or loose your ranking