Real Estate Outside the Box – Questioning the Value of Brick & Mortar
One of the many lessons that social media has taught us is that you need to go to where the conversations are happening, then skillfully listen and engage.
At the turn of the century, people would congregate down at the general store and swap stories around the pot belly stove. The corner drugstore followed where Biff and Peggy Sue made dove eyes at each other over malts, listening to Franki Valli and the Four Seasons. Later on, the water cooler down at the office became the meeting hot spot for catching all the latest gossip.
And now, conversations are happening at lightning speed across platforms like Twitter and Facebook. The Information Highway has become a runaway Japanese Bullet Train on Crack racing to satisfy a seemingly insatiable consumer hunger for interactivity, connection, and relevant data.
So how has this massive connection/communication paradigm shift affected traditional real estate practices, and, more importantly, the way in which we’ll do business in the future?
Perhaps one of the most recent telling effects in our industry has been the slow demise of brick and mortar real estate offices. Like many of their costly retail cousins (Borders, Linens N’ Things, Blockbuster, Mervyns, CompUSA, Ann Taylor, Foot Locker, Pier 1, and Zales, just to name a few), real estate offices across the country are downsizing or disappearing all together. With the severe downturn in our economy, and its adverse affect on the housing market, brokerage owners are hard-pressed to remain profitable, while, at the same time, keeping their stand-alone, agent-centric office spaces open.
Marc Davison of 1000Watt Blog fame observed this pending dilemma a few years back with his post “End Times for Brick and Mortar?”
In his article, Marc correlates the 2008 announcement by Starbucks to close 600 stores and makes the doom-saying premonition:
“Starbucks can’t exist unless people physically shop in their stores. But what about your real estate business model? Can you thrive without locations?”
Marc then poses the following questions:
- What is the fate of the retail real estate location?
- What is the benefit of a high rent storefront in today’s marketplace?
- Do those benefits outweigh the disadvantages?
- In 25 years will real estate be completely virtual?
- Will we see competitive virtual brokerages take market share and thrive or is that a pipe dream?
Just a year ago, at REBarCamp San Diego, Sherry Chris, President/CEO of Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate, facilitated a session entitled “What does the Future of Real Estate look like?” Listen in particular to some of the comments made by Stefan Swanepoel and Dale Kreiser of Exp Realty in Part 2 as they share their thoughts about the failure of traditional brick & mortar real estate offices, and some ideas on where they believe the future of real estate is heading.
So what is to be the fate of our precious time-honored real estate offices? The impressive Slate Entry and High-back Leather Chairs? The plush conference rooms with huge flat screen monitors? Our cherished cubicles? The semi-private offices, the coveted corner suites, the Top Agent of the Month parking space!?
Let’s consider some of the current trends in our industry:
- Walk-in traffic has decreased significantly.
- Agent floor time has become increasingly unproductive.
- More agents/brokers are working out of their homes.
- Office meetings are poorly attended.
- Mobile technology (like DocuSign) has empowered remote functionality
In order to remain solvent and succeed, businesses must venture out to where the consumers are, whether physically or digitally. We must be disciplined to listen intently, engage them creatively, and provide them with something of relevant meaning/value.
Allow me to pose some additional questions as food for thought/discussion:
- Have our traditional brick & mortar locations outlived their useful purpose?
- Is it realistic for real estate to become completely virtual?
- What kind of physical locations can create increased traffic and engagement?
- What basic services/benefits can agents/brokers receive from an office environment versus an at-home office?
- What basic services/benefits do office locations offer consumers?
I published a teaser post over on ActiveRain that’s generating a nice engaging comment stream!
For Your Further Reading Enjoyment:
- A Chicago area real estate broker gave up his lavish downtown Michigan Avenue office for the benefits of locating in a local supermarket.
- The Real Estate Lounge – a real estate office in disguise
- Is Walk-in Traffic critical to the Success of a 21st Century Brokerage?
- Office Space and the Floor Time Continuum by Teresa Boardman
- Spokane WA’s 1st Fully Mobile Real Estate Office!
- The Rise and Fall of Sales Meetings by Wendy Forsythe
- Stop Holding Office Meetings! by Matthew Ferrara
- The Magic of Mobile in Real Estate
Stephanie Crawford-@AgentSteph
Posted at 09:49h, 13 OctoberI rarely visit the office. I can do everything I need with a cheap multifunction printer/scanner and Docusign. Though a conference room is a nice thing to have. I believe co-working spaces will be the next big thing.
Eric Hempler
Posted at 11:25h, 13 OctoberThis is the direction I’m going already. Where there’s so much you can do online and/or from home why pay rent?
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 13:14h, 13 OctoberOne of the historical purposes for having an office has been to create synergy, positive dynamic, and promote espirt de corps. One of the potential dangers of eliminating the office is creating further isolation of agents. Is this an issue? Perhaps there are some who need accountability, encouragement from others. Definitely newer agents need some degree of connection/guidance, but does that have to come through an office environment?
Rich
Posted at 20:56h, 24 OctoberFrankly, I haven’t find much positive synergy in real estate offices. There are so few forward looking agents in Albuquerque that I look online to get inspired/motivated.
Drew Meyers
Posted at 11:58h, 25 OctoberInteresting. And, totally makes sense now that I think about it. You’ve gotta surround yourself with the forward thinking innovators…and those people are online.
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 23:49h, 26 OctoberRich – Unfortunately, I think the current downturn has had a huge negative impact on office synergy around the country. It’s hard not to get sucked into vacuum of negativity and despair. I don’t know that it’s necessarily a lack of forward looking agents, just a matter of being realistically optimistic in the face of adversity!….
Joe
Posted at 15:25h, 13 OctoberGood article, along with the references. Look at bookstores and others. I believe bricks/mortar is obsolete…I do everything on the web using tools provided by our MLS & CAR, and my iPad
VickiLloyd
Posted at 17:13h, 13 OctoberMy office of 15 agents is totally virtual. We all work out of our own homes, and when we need to have a meeting (about 2 times per year) we get together either at someone’s home, a restaurant, or community center. We meet our buyer clients at the closest Starbucks to the homes we will be showing, and almost always meet seller clients in their homes.
When I started in the mid-1990s, the office still got sign or ad calls, so floor time was valuable to get new business. We even got occasional walk-ins from the general traffic in the shopping center where we were located. The technology equipment then was more expensive than most agents could afford in their homes, so a brick & mortar office made sense. Today, not so much. The only reason I can see for a physical real estate office is if you don’t have room in your home, or you have noisy children who would interrupt you.
Palmetto Choice
Posted at 10:05h, 18 OctoberI have 7 agents and work from home. We operate the same as you have described, and my agents love it. Because of the decrease in overhead it provides me the opportunity to offer my agents a better commission split; allowing the agents to advertise their way, secure personal website, and it eliminates any office confusion that I have experienced as a broker with B&M.
Chris Lefebvre
Posted at 18:33h, 13 OctoberGreat article Rich. If you want to see something really different, check out my broker (eXp Realty). We are 2 years old now and already open for business in 19 states with more coming on. Our broker is different in that we are totally virtual with a true virtual office. Agents can log in, walk around a virtual office with an avatar, go into different buildings and rooms, talk with other agents and colleagues and administrative staff, attend training sessions, watch recorded training sessions, share screens, lead meetings, conduct business, etc. If you would like to take a tour of our virtual office look for me online by googling “Chris Lefebvre Real Estate” and you will find me.
Chris Lefebvre
Posted at 01:33h, 14 OctoberGreat article Rich. If you want to see something really different, check out my broker (eXp Realty). We are 2 years old now and already open for business in 19 states with more coming on. Our broker is different in that we are totally virtual with a true virtual office. Agents can log in, walk around a virtual office with an avatar, go into different buildings and rooms, talk with other agents and colleagues and administrative staff, attend training sessions, watch recorded training sessions, share screens, lead meetings, conduct business, etc. If you would like to take a tour of our virtual office look for me online by googling “Chris Lefebvre Real Estate” and you will find me.
Home Auctions in Florida
Posted at 14:09h, 17 OctoberSocial Media Marketing is the one of the most trending topics in online marketing today. Companies can use social media channels as a way for increasing its goodwills and trustworthiness which may ultimately result in better branding.
Domain registration
Posted at 02:32h, 19 OctoberExcellent blogs . I will keep visiting this blog very often.thanks to sharing the wonderful articles
Sam DeBord, SeattleHome.com
Posted at 09:24h, 20 OctoberI got to your article late Rich, but I’m glad I read it. Great analysis. I think that there is still room for brick and mortar, but only in a niche setting. The vast majority of buyers and seller want to meet you at the property, not trudge across town to your office. People, especially in metropolitan locations, have busier schedules and less free time to spend in transit. We can always have a couple of traditional offices, but the need for every neighborhood to have its own brick and mortar has really gone away.
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 13:15h, 20 OctoberThanks for stopping by and reading my article, Sam. It’s a fascinating study. There are so many people in our biz who are entrenched in tradition and just simply ‘expect’ a more conventional approach to office space. The whole premise of my post was to stimulate thought on what do agents/brokers ‘really’ need and what is the most valuable space for consumers? Do the traditional brick & mortar locations currently satisfy both cost-effectively and practically? Thanks again for your comments!
Jane
Posted at 17:09h, 21 OctoberOur team concept used to include an entire wing at an office, paying for everything for space and utilities, to computers and post it notes. Not so today! Our professional agents work from home, and we provide them with stellar leads, giving them more value than any desk chair or sign rider we ever purchased!… Evolution!
Jimmy8814
Posted at 03:56h, 24 October[comment deleted]
Jimmy8814
Posted at 04:02h, 24 OctoberIf you want a lot of blog posts, hot air, big talk, and not very any sales, the Rich Jacobsen is the agent for you. He’s long on talk and short on closings. That’s why he failed out of real estate and went to Brio Realty.
Drew Meyers
Posted at 05:50h, 24 OctoberJimmy-
Not sure what your grudge is against Rich, but any further personal comments will be deleted. Talk about the issue being discussed (office of the future), or nothing at all.
Jimmy8814
Posted at 23:15h, 25 October[comment removed. discussion needs to be about the issue at hand, not the people having the discussion]
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 13:06h, 24 OctoberFor Jimmy8814: First, if you’re going to leave a comment, please do so with a legitimate email address versus hiding behind anonymity. Secondly, try to stay on topic and actually add value to the conversation. And lastly, my license was held by Brio Realty for just over a year and was one of the conditions of my employment as a Community Manager with ActiveRain.
Jimmy8814
Posted at 23:13h, 25 OctoberValue is pointing out to the people on here that you have NO IDEA what you are talking about when it comes to SELLING real estate. Blogging or talking about real estate is your speciality.
Rich’s stats for 2011:
1 Listing sold
3 Buyers sales
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 23:57h, 25 OctoberJimmy: I’m not sure exactly what your gripe is with me or why you’re launching your own little witch hunt. I’m not attempting to sell real estate here, simply leading a discussion on the state of traditional brick & mortar real estate offices. If you want to be taken seriously, then stop hiding behind a wall of anonymity. Otherwise, do your trolling elsewhere….
Ian Flannigan
Posted at 05:57h, 25 OctoberWow, I happen to stumble across this article. Today is October 25th 2017, years after this was published. The future of real estate brokerage is here. eXp Realty provides a technology platform unlike any other brokerage.
eXp is built around the agent not the Broker/Owner. With no bricks and mortar and operating 100% in the cloud,
all of the typical expenses of a brokerage are non existent, allowing the agent owners to receive that revenue in the form of revenue share and equity/stock as the company grows. The eXp model is too innovative to try to explain in a simple post on this thread. If you come across this post and would like to have a conversation about the model I’d be more than happy. Ian Flannigan 214.213.1737 [email protected]
Jeremy Rivera
Posted at 15:51h, 24 OctoberIf you do lose a brick and mortar, then you get even more handicapped against brokers, who are going to be the only ones who can compete in Google local for Mapped searches like “city name realtor”. Go to yelp, yellowpages.com, etc and try to get listed W/O an address…. No listing = no reviews and no traffic and no trusted inbound links. Since Local Search is getting bigger and bigger due to Mobile use of review sites, I think that brick and mortar brokers will hold advantage (if they know what they’re doing).
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 17:28h, 24 OctoberJeremy: Thanks for your comment. Personally, I don’t think we’re going lose office locations altogether, per se, just what they look like, where they’re located, what specific needs they serve, etc. I see smaller locations, situated in places where there is more consistent consumer traffic, offering technologies and resources, more like a business hub, rather than the full blown high-expense conventional space….JMHO. But then, what do I know. I’m just full of hot air…
mikec (@blogboy2)
Posted at 15:37h, 27 OctoberI listened to the entire “What does the Future of Real Estate look like?” session by Sherry Chris. I appreciate that you posted that. It’s so great to be able to enjoy the benefits of that past discussion when there’s no way I could have been there. Thanks again. 😉
Jimmy8814
Posted at 16:40h, 01 November[comment removed by moderator]
Drew Meyers
Posted at 16:46h, 01 Novemberjimmy-
I don’t ban people often (actually i don’t know if i ever have), but one more comment about people rather than the issue at hand and you’ll be the first. There is no reason for me (or Rich) to tolerate these types of comments on this blog.
Jimmy8814
Posted at 16:42h, 01 November[comment removed by moderator]
Rich Jacobson
Posted at 12:49h, 04 NovemberDear Jimmy8814: http://activerain.com/blogsview/2586917/reversing-the-tide-of-negativity-in-a-challenging-market
Maureen McCabe
Posted at 10:55h, 05 NovemberWe just closed a big, big office which no one (agents) were coming into much anymore but then opened two small offices. I had NOT gone into the office much in years but I did continue to use it to meet clients. I am able to do a lot of work with out an office but I have never been able to get into writing a contract at Starbucks, or prequalifying a buyer in McDonalds, so I have continued to meet clients at the office. Our new location is really, really brick and mortar and so far a lot of fun. We are hoping for walk in traffic since we are in a heavy traffic area but maybe that will not happen…
I read this when it was first posted but had to come back to see Jimmy8814 behaving badly.